Skip to content
ADVERTISEMENT

What a fake job taught me about hiring

Richard Edge, founder at Careerships, discusses what his fake job adverts revealed about hiring and why meaningful conversations matter more than application numbers.

Richard edge headshot high res
ADVERTISEMENT

In April I posted a job on LinkedIn for a director of strategy. The first line said, in plain words, “please don’t apply, this is not a real job”.

350 people applied in a week. In September I tried again. About 400 people applied in the first 30 minutes. By six hours it was 920, and I took it down.

Nobody pointed out that the job was fake.

I spent years as an HR director, on the other side of those inboxes. So my first reaction was not to blame the applicants. It was to feel for whoever has to read them. Because nobody reads 920 applications properly. Not in six hours, and not in six days.

What I found in the pile

ADVERTISEMENT

Most applicants had no relevant experience for a director of strategy role. Not one gave me a reason to look twice. Around 30 also sent me a connection request, some with notes clearly written by artificial intelligence (AI), a few identical word for word, and one or two about a different job altogether.

It is easy to call that careless. I think it is something sadder. People have learned that applying costs nothing and hearing back is rare. So they click, and click again, and hope.

The front door has moved

ADVERTISEMENT

For many senior roles, the advert is no longer the front door. It is the last resort. The best people are often found before a role is ever advertised, through a conversation, a referral, or someone who already knows their work.

That is uncomfortable for HR, because we’ve worked hard to build fair, open processes. Openness still matters. But an advert that draws 920 clicks in six hours is not open in any useful sense. It is a lottery, and the strongest candidates are the ones most likely to be lost in it.

ADVERTISEMENT

If I were back in the HR chair

ADVERTISEMENT

I would ask one question that only a reader can answer. A single, specific question in the advert separates the readers from the clickers in seconds.

I would remember that every applicant is a future customer, employee or referrer. All 920 formed a view of the brand behind that advert. A short, honest reply costs very little and says a great deal.

I would build the bench before I needed it. Know who the good people in your sector are and stay in touch with them. I call it watering the network. If you only reach out when there is a vacancy, you are already late.

And I would stop treating the number of applications as a measure of success. Volume tells you how easy the button was to press. It tells you nothing about who you have found.

ADVERTISEMENT

What I tell the people I work with

In my experience, expertise is now only around a third of how senior people are judged. The rest is how well you use AI in your own work, and the relationships that bring opportunities to you before they are advertised. That thinking sits behind the ARC model I have developed.

In practice it means writing to a person, not a portal. Researching deeper than anyone else. And making the dice roll nobody else is making, even something as old-fashioned as a handwritten letter. When hundreds take the same route, the person who takes a different one is remembered.

Not a story about careless candidates

An advert asked people not to apply, and 1,270 did. That tells us less about the people applying than about a hiring system that has made applying effortless and being noticed harder than ever.

ADVERTISEMENT

HR can’t fix that on its own. But we can stop counting clicks, and start counting conversations.

Richard Edge MBA, FCIPD, LLB is founder of Careerships