Skip to content
ADVERTISEMENT

Recruitment technology standards are welcome – but trust must extend across the entire hiring process

Susie Thomson examines the importance of consistent standards and accountability across the increasingly digital recruitment process.

Susie thomson headshot
ADVERTISEMENT

The launch of a new national standard for recruitment technology by the Association of RecTech Providers (ARTP) is a welcome sign that the recruitment industry is taking the issues of trust, transparency and accountability increasingly seriously.

As technology, and particularly artificial intelligence (AI), becomes embedded across more stages of recruitment, employers need confidence that the tools they use are appropriate, secure and capable of supporting fair and responsible decision-making. But technology does not operate in isolation.

A candidate may move through an applicant tracking system, automated screening tools, digital identity verification, right-to-work checks, employment and education verification, criminal record screening and other forms of background screening before an appointment is made and each part of that journey can influence both the candidate experience and the employer’s ultimate hiring decision. So, while setting standards specifically for recruitment technology is a positive development, the wider opportunity is to ensure that high standards are applied across the entire hiring ecosystem.

Standards need substance behind them

One of the challenges employers increasingly face is distinguishing between a provider that says it follows good practice and one that can actually demonstrate it. A supplier may offer impressive technology, sophisticated automation or a seamless candidate interface but employers still need to ask what sits behind that service. How is candidate information protected? Who remains accountable for decisions? How are third-party suppliers managed? What happens when information is challenged? Are processes legally compliant? And, importantly, can the organisation demonstrate that its policies are actually being followed?

ADVERTISEMENT

These questions become even more important as AI is introduced into recruitment and screening. The speed and sophistication of technology can create an understandable temptation to automate more of the hiring journey. But efficiency should never be mistaken for assurance. Employers ultimately remain responsible for the decisions they make about individuals, regardless of the technology or external providers supporting those decisions.

Human oversight, transparency and clearly defined accountability therefore need to remain fundamental.

Accreditation provides an important benchmark

ADVERTISEMENT

This principle is well established within the professional background screening sector. PBSA was founded more than two decades ago with advancing standards, ethics and professional practice at the heart of its purpose and accreditation has subsequently become an important mechanism for demonstrating those standards in practice.

PBSA’s Background Screening Organisation Accreditation Programme (BSOAP), which has now been expanded across the UK and Europe, evaluates screening organisations against defined professional standards rather than relying on self-declaration alone. The programme examines six critical areas, including information security, legal and compliance requirements, client education, researcher and data standards, verification services and general business practices. Organisations undergo independent auditing, with continuing surveillance built into the accreditation cycle. That distinction matters.

ADVERTISEMENT

Standards have the greatest value when customers understand what sits behind them: what has been assessed, who has assessed it and whether compliance continues to be monitored after accreditation has been awarded.

ADVERTISEMENT

The hiring ecosystem is becoming interconnected

The introduction of more standards across recruitment also reflects a much wider change taking place. The traditional boundaries between recruitment technology, identity verification, background screening, workforce compliance and HR systems are disappearing.

Increasingly, these services connect with one another, exchange data and form part of the same digital hiring journey. That makes collaboration between different parts of the recruitment profession increasingly important. An employer should not have to be an expert in every piece of technology or every form of screening it procures.

It should, however, be able to identify providers that can demonstrate professional competence, responsible data practices, transparency and appropriate governance. This is particularly important where technology affects decisions about whether an individual progresses through recruitment.

ADVERTISEMENT

A highly sophisticated hiring system is of limited value if the information feeding into it is unreliable, poorly obtained or inadequately protected. Equally, robust background screening cannot compensate for an automated recruitment process that is opaque, biased or lacking meaningful human oversight. Trust has to exist throughout the chain.

Raising standards should be a shared ambition

For that reason, initiatives designed to improve standards within recruitment technology should be welcomed. There should not be a choice between innovation and good governance. Done properly, standards can support innovation by giving employers greater confidence to adopt new technologies while providing reputable providers with a clearer way to demonstrate the quality of what they offer.

As recruitment becomes increasingly digital, the next stage should be about connecting these conversations. Recruitment technology providers, screening organisations, employers, policymakers and professional bodies all have a role to play in ensuring that faster hiring also becomes safer, fairer and more transparent.

The objective should not simply be to introduce more standards. It should be a hiring ecosystem in which employers and candidates can understand what good looks like and have confidence that organisations claiming to meet those standards can demonstrate that they do.

ADVERTISEMENT

Susie Thomson is chair of the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA)