Skip to content
ADVERTISEMENT

Britain’s recruitment downturn could trigger a new wave of consolidation

Scott Ellam, founder and CEO at XCE, discusses why acquisitions in people-led businesses should protect workforce autonomy, retain key staff and offer earned ownership.

Scott
ADVERTISEMENT

Deals in people-led businesses are usually judged on price and structure. They are actually decided by who is still there eighteen months later. The UK hiring market has stopped falling. Permanent placements stabilised in July, ending a 45-month downturn, according to the KPMG and REC UK Report on Jobs. At the same time, RSM recorded 36 UK recruitment and workforce solutions transactions in the first half of 2026, most of them involving privately owned, founder-led sellers.

Those two facts together mean a lot of people are about to find out who their employer is going to be. In knowledge and people-led businesses, that is the part of a transaction that determines whether it worked, and it is the part that gets the least design attention.

The retention problem is designed in, not accidental

When an acquisition of a specialist service firm underperforms, the explanation offered afterwards is usually cultural. People did not settle. The fit was not right. That framing lets everyone off.

In practice, the losses are engineered by the integration plan itself. Consider what a standard post-deal programme asks of a high performer in the first year. Learn a new system. Adopt a new brand in front of clients who chose the old one. Accept a revised commission or bonus structure designed for consistency across a wider group. Report to a new layer of management with no history in their market. Watch their founder, who recruited them and backed them, move into a transitional role and then out.

ADVERTISEMENT

Every one of those is defensible on its own. Together they communicate something specific: the thing you were part of has been replaced by something larger, and your position in it is worse than it was. The people with the strongest external market, which is to say the ones the buyer most needed to keep, are best placed to act on that message.

This is why a workforce plan cannot begin after completion. By then the signals have been sent.

Autonomy is a retention instrument

ADVERTISEMENT

The alternative starts from an unusual premise for a buyer: that the acquired business was already working, and the job is to remove what constrained it rather than to change what defined it.

In practice that means the company keeps its name, its management team and full authority over how it runs day to day. Client ownership does not move. Team structures do not get redesigned to fit a group template. What changes is the support underneath: finance, back-office functions, access to capital, and the removal of the dependency on a single owner for decisions, guarantees and cash.

ADVERTISEMENT

This approach is best described as decentralised acquisition with permanent hold. Decentralised because the operating businesses are not merged into one another. Permanent because there is no fund life and no requirement to sell the business on in three to five years, which is what usually forces a buyer to standardise everything in the first place.

ADVERTISEMENT

The workforce effect is straightforward. If nothing that a consultant values is being taken away, there is nothing for them to defend against, and the question of whether to stay never becomes urgent.

Earned ownership, not retention bonuses

Autonomy prevents loss. It does not, on its own, create commitment. That requires people to hold something that grows.

Earned ownership means performance-based equity granted against revenue, profit and long-term value, rather than issued on arrival as an inducement. The distinction matters more than it sounds. A retention bonus buys time and creates a cliff edge on the date it vests. Earned ownership creates a claim on something the individual can keep increasing, and it is defensible to everyone else in the business because the basis is visible: you generate the performance, you earn the ownership.

ADVERTISEMENT

It is worth being honest about what the usual tools achieve. Salary secures attendance. Commission secures activity. Neither secures the discretionary effort that builds a business over a decade, and neither gives someone a reason to turn down the approach that lands in their inbox six months after completion.

Ownership is earned, not given. That is a harder promise to make and a much easier one to keep.

The test worth applying

Any leader evaluating an acquisition, on either side of it, can get to the substance with three questions. What is being taken away from the people who generate the revenue? What is being given back to them, and on what basis do they earn it? And how long does the new owner intend to hold the business, because that answer determines everything else.

XCE is a UK-listed international executive recruitment group. We acquire profitable owner-managed recruitment firms, hire revenue-generating billing consultants, and strengthen the balance sheet through an integrated Bitcoin treasury. Our first acquisition, James Gray, joined on that basis and kept its name, its leadership and its way of working. Twelve people joined the group, ten of them billing.

ADVERTISEMENT

Deals in people businesses are not won at completion. They are won in the second year, in the quiet decision each of those people makes about whether this is still somewhere they want to build.

Scott Ellam is founder and CEO of XCE (Connecting Excellence Group PLC)