Skip to content
ADVERTISEMENT

A skills-first approach can widen the talent pool

Matt Sharp, senior vice president of EMEA at ICIMS, explains the importance of a skills-first approach amidst the growing NEET challenge in the workplace.

Msharp grad
ADVERTISEMENT

With the Government placing renewed emphasis on economic opportunity and helping more people access work, and almost one million young people being classed as not in education, employment or training (NEET), the route into work deserves urgent attention from employers as well as policymakers.

For businesses struggling to fill vacancies and close skills gaps, the NEET challenge is a talent-matching problem. Skills-first hiring is the practice of assessing candidates on demonstrated capability and potential rather than qualifications, job titles or previous employment history. Employers that make the shift widen their candidate pool without lowering their standards.

Why is the labour market getting harder for young people?

Recent data shows that EMEA hiring fell 20% month-on-month in August, the sharpest single-month drop of the year, while applications declined by 7%. Job openings remained 21% above their August 2025 baseline, although growth has now turned negative for two consecutive months. While some of this reflects the seasonal slowdown typically seen across the region in August, the figures point to a wider cooling in employer demand and candidate engagement.

The UK is showing a similar pattern of caution. The latest Office for National Statistics (ONS) labour market data shows UK vacancies fell to 702,000 in June-August 2026. There were also 2.5 unemployed people per vacancy, up from 2.3 a year earlier, suggesting a less competitive labour market for employers than in previous years.

ADVERTISEMENT

Together, these figures point to a more selective recruitment environment in which businesses are under pressure to make every hire count, while candidates, particularly those entering the workforce for the first time, face greater competition for fewer opportunities.

Applicants per opening in EMEA have now declined for five consecutive months. A smaller pool per role raises the cost of every candidate an employer screens out for reasons that were never essential to the job. When there were more applicants than a team could work through, a long list of preferred qualifications may have felt like a reasonable filter. But as recruitment becomes more cautious, that same approach risks excluding candidates the business needs, particularly younger applicants who may have less formal experience but offer transferable skills, adaptability and the potential to develop.

Hospitality, healthcare, retail and other service industries feel this first, because they hire at a high volume and their entry-level roles are the ones most often described in terms of prior experience. Young people navigating the transition from education into employment are among the first to be filtered, because they have the least to show against criteria built around experience.

ADVERTISEMENT

That should make HR leaders question whether traditional approaches to recruitment are identifying the talent that is actually available. Capability is difficult to recognise when recruitment processes are designed to select candidates based on previous experience, qualifications and familiar career paths.

What does moving beyond the CV actually mean?

ADVERTISEMENT

For many young people, the biggest barrier to employment is the catch-22 of entry-level recruitment. Employers want experience, and candidates cannot gain that without first being given an opportunity.

ADVERTISEMENT

A skills-first approach can help break that cycle. Employers should weigh transferable skills, aptitude and potential alongside qualifications, job titles or previous employment. Communication, problem-solving, adaptability, collaboration and a willingness to learn can matter as much to long-term success as a candidate’s employment history.

This does not mean abandoning qualifications where they are genuinely necessary. It means creating a deliberate distinction between essential requirements and criteria that have simply become embedded in a job description over time.

Understanding what candidates really need to be able to do to succeed in a role gives hiring teams a much broader pool of candidates, including young people taking their first steps beyond education.

A practical way to start is to sort every requirement into what a candidate must know on day one and what they can reasonably learn in the first 90 days. Most requirements belong in the second group and moving them there widens the pipeline and lowers time to fill.

ADVERTISEMENT

How can AI help without filtering people out?

Technology has an important role to play in making this shift possible, though the value is not where most people assume.

Much of the conversation about AI in hiring is still about processing applications faster. The more useful application is sustaining relationships with candidates long before they are ready to be hired. Students and school leavers may be twelve months or more away from entering the workforce, and most recruiting teams have never had the capacity to stay meaningfully connected across that timeline. Automation makes it possible.

There is also considerable value already sitting inside most organisations. Employers hold years of candidate records, including strong applicants who narrowly missed out and early-career profiles that went dormant. AI can resurface those people against new openings by matching skills and capabilities rather than relying solely on job titles or conventional career histories. A young person who applied once and heard nothing is no longer lost to the business permanently.

For younger candidates with limited work experience, the ability to read capability differently matters most. Someone who has not held a formal role may have demonstrated teamwork through volunteering or sport, resilience through caring responsibilities, problem-solving through education or entrepreneurial initiative through a personal project.

ADVERTISEMENT

Throughout all of this, people need to stay in control. Recruiting teams should be able to decide where automation is used, how much autonomy it has and at what point a person reviews the outcome. Recruitment is ultimately about people, and hiring managers need to understand why a candidate has been identified as a potential fit, challenge assumptions and apply context and judgement. Used responsibly, AI can help widen the aperture through which they assess teams assess talent and surface candidates a keyword match would never return.

The results are already visible. One large healthcare provider now uses automated candidate discovery and outreach to engage future clinicians long before they enter the workforce, drawing on the talent data it had already collected rather than starting each search from scratch. Sustained engagement across cycles of more than a year has tripled the size of its candidate database, giving recruiters a pool of known, interested people to draw on when roles open. The principle travels well beyond healthcare. Building a relationship with someone at the point they are deciding what to do next, rather than at the point they meet a job specification, changes who is available to hire later.

The NEET challenge is an opportunity for talent acquisition leaders to rethink what talent looks like. At a moment when young people are weighing up their future options, employers have an important opportunity to make sure employment is a visible and accessible part of that future.

The businesses that succeed in the years ahead may be those that become better at recognising potential before it becomes experience.

Matt Sharp is senior vice president of EMEA at ICIMS